DUMB SOLUTIONS TO DUMB PROBLEMS

Just got back from a Caribbean cruise. Not too shabby. The food was outstanding, and our every wish was the wait-staff’s command.

At one dinner, the fig cake was wonderful. Without asking, Alvin produced another piece. The next day, the dessert offerings were mediocre. I asked Alvin if they had any more fig cake roaming around.

“So sorry, Mr. Wilson. We throw out our leftovers every evening.”

A ton of filet mignon, a hundred gallons of milk, pitched overboard each day. Impoverished Third World people just outside the porthole. Do you see the absurdity? Poor people starve as we debate the feasibility and contingencies of ending starvation.

I might be dumb, but moving food a couple hundred yards from where it is to where it ought to be, should be a no-brainer. Maybe that’s the point.

A modest proposal: Look at every need, every looming crisis and injustice, through dumb eyes, with the social naiveté of your run-of-the-mill second grader, and think up a dumb solution. Once I had a bunch of dumb second graders in my Hebrew School. We’d raid the dumpster behind Bruegger’s each week, pick out that day’s bagel overrun, and unceremoniously drop it off at the Union Mission. Just plain dumb.

We also occasionally come across dumb adults. The restaurateurs who give their leftovers to Second Harvest and the folks who deliver Meals on Wheels are a bunch of dumbbells, too.

Think dumb along with me: There has to be some way to get that food from the Carnival Glory to impoverished islanders, if we were just dumb enough to figure it out. There should be some better way to get bagels to the homeless than second graders stealing them out of dumpsters.

Ask a dumb second grader how to stop the starvation in Myanmar. He could tell you in a second: Put the Marines in the vanguard and invade it. Set up soup kitchens and reconstruction projects until the people can get on their own feet. Damn the pigwhistle generals and their peashooter army. Just do it.

Illegal immigration? I may not know the solution, but it will start with a dumb supposition. Of this I am sure. In second grade, we learned that this is the Land of Opportunity. Then the teacher made us memorize the inscription on the Statue of Liberty, you know, “your tired, your poor, your huddled masses,” and all that.

At the nub, the desire to for people to immigrate to our soil attests that we are doing something right. I dare believe that even the vast majority of illegal immigrants do not think us to be a bunch of suckers, but a nation founded on compassion and fairness.
This is the beginning of the dumb solution: Read the Statue’s inscription and sing a stanza of America the Beautiful, just like we did in second grade. Then feel honored, damn it, that the tired and the poor wish to make a home among us, not revile in them like a hoard of invading locusts. Our disposition would be to open doors, enabling a transition, not criminalizing it.

What of the specious arguments about the “legitimacy” of immigrants in earlier generations? Only a half-truth. My grandparents were the lucky ones. They arrived just before the doors of immigration slammed shut in the early 20’s. But, I know my grandparents’ moxie. Had it been a couple of years later, if they could have figured out a way to enter the country illegally, they would have. Instead, ship after ship was turned back at port, and thousands of potential immigrants who could have been saved were forced to return, remanded a decade later to the Third Reich, instead of Land of the Free.

How will we resolve the present crisis? I’m not exactly sure, but this I believe: We will find a way, and the answer is likely to be dumb. But, as my saintly mother would say, “Only with a good spirit.” A good spirit, not a misanthropic one, will find a way.

Will dumbing-down alone cure all society’s ills? No, but the starting point must be to presuppose that we will look at the world with the naïve credulity of a second grader. We need assume that the solutions to our problems are basically no-brainers. We need sophistication only to lop off the rough edges, not undo the solutions with a bunch of phony smoke-and-mirrors. A dopey kid could tell you what to do with the Glory’s leftovers. Just ask him.